HomeBusiness10 Finest Thrift Stores in Fayetteville NC with Budget Items

10 Finest Thrift Stores in Fayetteville NC with Budget Items

Published on


Thrift stores in Fayetteville NC are a great way to save money while also promoting sustainability and reducing trash. If you enjoy the rush of scoring a great bargain or the thrill of stumbling upon a one-of-a-kind vintage item, thrift shopping may become your new favorite pastime.

Join Our Facebook Group

Introducing our new group for Buying and Selling liquidation goods and merchandise!

Giveaways Facebook Group

Group Link: https://www.facebook.com/groups/937259116458055/

Find exclusive deals and merchandise opportunities!

However, it can be difficult to know where to begin given the number of thrift stores. This post will explore the world of thrift shopping in more detail and offer a list of some of the top stores in the area. We’ll go over everything you need to know to become a pro thrift shopper, from little-known gems to well-known brands.

A number of thrift shops in the city of Fayetteville, NC, give one-of-a-kind goods at competitive prices. The city has something for everyone. Whether you’re on a tight budget, a fan seeking out unique items, or you enjoy the thrill of the hunt.

In this piece, we’ll examine in greater detail the best thrift shops in Fayetteville, including Lily Kat’s Consignment and 4th John’s thrift stores in Fayetteville NC. Each of these shops has a distinct atmosphere, product assortment, and devoted customer base. Join us as we discover the finest Fayetteville thrift shops and all they have to offer.

Thrift Stores in Fayetteville NC:

Once upon a time

Once upon a time - thrift stores fayetteville nc

Located in Fayetteville, North Carolina, Once Once a Time Thrift Shop is a unique and well-liked business. In keeping with its name, the shop sells a wide range of used goods and has a nostalgic, whimsical vibe.

Both residents and visitors enjoy hanging out at the shop because of its friendly personnel and welcoming atmosphere. Anyone can find something at Once Once a Time, which carries anything from home products and decor to antique apparel and accessories.

Customers can discover some undiscovered gems from the past because of the store’s wide assortment of books, films, and music. Both historical items that pay homage to the area’s past and military-themed objects are frequently featured on Once Once a Time.

Because of its unique appeal and dedication to the neighborhood, the shop has grown to be a cherished place to be. You have to check out their amazing collection. Go and pay them a visit super soon!

Address: The Whaley Center, 4560 Yadkin Rd, Fayetteville, NC 28303, US

Phone: +1 910-867-6822

Get Directions

Plato’s Closet

Plato's Closet Naples - thrift stores fayetteville nc

Plato’s Closet is one among the other thrift stores in Fayetteville NC. This store is different from Once upon a time which has a nostalgic vibe. Plato is more trendy and has fashionable clothes for teenagers.

The store follows the thrifting concept very well as it deals in gently used clothing. It gives the customers an opportunity to update their closet and give out a new vibe which also comes in budget.

It is majorly popular among college students who can find affordable yet trendy clothing here. The shop believes in sustainability and is working for a sustainable environment. It reduces the burden of fast fashion by dealing in gently used clothes.

Customers love the store’s aesthetics and the products available here. The inventory is constantly changing so you can always find the trend there. Visit the store to know what’s in it for you!

Address: 4550 Yadkin Rd, Fayetteville, NC 28303, US

Phone: +1 910-867-8009

Get Directions

Lily kat’s Consignment Boutique

Lily kat's consignment boutique - thrift stores fayetteville nc

Consignment boutiques typically offer a curated selection of gently used clothing and accessories at a discounted price. Also, they might provide consignment options, where customers can bring in their own goods to sell in exchange for a cut of the proceeds.

The consignment shop Lily Kat’s Consignment is situated in Fayetteville, North Carolina. For more than ten years, the community has flocked to this family-run business because it provides a large selection of gently worn apparel, accessories, and home goods at reasonable costs.

The store has a friendly environment with such skilled staff. The aesthetics of the store makes you wanna stay there forever. From vintage items to luxurious designer bags, you can find almost everything there. Lily Kat’s commitment to quality sets them apart from other consignment shops.

Every item is carefully checked before being placed up for sale, so only the best things make it onto the shelves. This translates to consumers being able to purchase goods with confidence and without breaking the wallet. It is a customer-friendly store and you have to shop from there.

Address: 817 Elm St, Fayetteville, NC 28303, US

Phone: +1 910-223-0170

Get Directions



The resale shop Goodwill is situated near Fayetteville, North Carolina. For both men and women, the shop specializes in providing a large selection of high-quality, gently-used apparel, shoes, and accessories.

The fashionable apparel products available at Goodwill are well renowned for being meticulously picked to appeal to a wide range of buyers. Customers are invited to return frequently to view the most recent arrivals because the store’s inventory is continuously changing.

Designer purses, jewelry, and shoes are some of the often purchased things at Goodwill, along with a variety of vintage and retro clothing items. People that use the consignment model can get more use out of their apparel because they can sell items they no longer need or use for cash.

It’s no surprise that this consignment store has become a favorite among locals and tourists alike given its continuously changing inventory, first-rate customer service, and dedication to sustainability. Give this store a visit to check out what they have in store for you!

Address: 3801 Raeford Rd, Fayetteville, NC 28304, US

Phone: +1 910-486-8716

Get Directions

The Whaley Center

The Whaley Center - thrift stores fayetteville nc

The historic Whaley Center building houses the Fayetteville Area Habitat for Humanity, which operates the Whaley Center Thrift Shop. The thrift shop offers a variety of goods for sale, including electronics, furniture, housewares, and apparel.

The Fayetteville Area Habitat for Humanity builds affordable homes for people in need with the help of revenues from the thrift shop. Shopping at the Store not only helps a worthy cause but protects the environment by encouraging the reuse of goods that might otherwise wind up in landfills.

Volunteers run the thrift shop, which has reasonable prices on all of its goods. It is accessible to everyone and a well-liked spot for folks hoping to score a deal to shop. While new items are constantly being added to the inventory, customers are attracted to revisit the store. Have a great time thrift shopping at the store.

Address: 4544 Yadkin Rd, Fayetteville, NC 28303, US

Phone: +1 910-867-6822

Get Directions

New & Nearly New Thrift shop

New & Nearly New Thrift shop - thrift stores fayetteville nc

New & Nearly New Thrift Store is a well-known consignment and resale store. A large range of gently used apparel, shoes, accessories, furniture, and home products are available at the shop, all at competitive prices. The Store’s consignment program is one of its special features.

Clients are welcome to bring their lightly used items into the shop, and the staff will sell them on their behalf. Consigning is a great way for homeowners to earn extra money while organizing their houses because consignors receive a portion of the sale price once their items are sold.

Anything from luxury clothing and accessories to vintage and retro things are available to customers. Also, the shop sells a variety of home decor goods like carpets, lamps, and artwork. The Store is well-known for its reasonable prices, creative consignment programme, and dedication to giving back to the community.

The shop often contributes a portion of its earnings to local charities and groups. It also collaborates with area schools and churches to help families in need by donating clothing and household goods. Hence, it is a people’s choice store to enjoy the thrift culture while being sustainable.

Address: 810 Bragg Blvd, Fayetteville, NC 28301, US

Phone: +1 910-779-3531

Get Directions

Myrover-Reese Thrift Store

Myrover-Reese Thrift Store - thrift stores fayetteville nc

The Myrover-Reese Thrift Store is a renowned consignment shop. The Myrover-Reese Fellowship Houses, a nonprofit company that offers housing and support services for people recovering from alcoholism and drug addiction, runs the shop.

The thrift shop has a large selection of stuff, all at reasonable prices, including apparel, shoes, furniture, books, and household goods. The shop’s inventory is always changing because new items are introduced every day.

Anything from high-end designer apparel and accessories to standard products like bedding and kitchenware are available for customers. Also, the Store supports the Myrover-Reese Fellowship Houses’ goal of giving people in addiction recovery accommodation and support services.

The organization’s programmes and services, which include transitional housing, counseling, and job training, are supported by the store’s profits. Enjoy thrifting with your group at the store by visiting them.

Address: 1336 Clinton Rd, Fayetteville, NC 28312, US

Phone: +1 910-223-1148

Get Directions

Sacks 2.0 Consignment 

Sacks 2.0 Consignment - thrift stores fayetteville nc

Sacks 2.0 Consignment Fayetteville, NC is a very liked thrift store. Anyone looking for high-end fashion items without the designer price tag will find a unique shopping experience at the shop.

As soon as you enter Sacks 2.0, you’ll note the neatly arranged racks of apparel, shoes, and accessories. The shop boasts an incredible assortment of luxury goods that have been owned before but are still in excellent shape, from Chanel handbags to Gucci sunglasses.

The reasonable prices of Sacks 2.0’s products are one of its outstanding features. Despite being designer goods, the prices are frequently up to 70% less than the suggested retail price. This enables those on a tight budget to nonetheless appreciate high-end clothing.

For those wishing to sell their high-end products, Sacks 2.0 also offers a consignment programme. The steps are simple, and the staff will walk you through each one. Visit the store super soon!

Address: 3035-B Boone Trail, Fayetteville, NC 28304, US

Phone: +1 910-491-3682

Get Directions

Yard Sales Store

Yard Sales Store

Yard sales are a fantastic place to find wonderful prices on unique and fascinating stuff. What if, though, you discovered a yard sale that never ends? Rockfish Yard Sale Shop in Fayetteville, NC, is the only place to go. A wonderful store of used items, Rockfish Yard Sale Shop includes everything from furniture and home décor to apparel and toys.

The shop has a large area with aisles of nicely arranged merchandise, making it simple to browse and discover what you’re searching for. Everything in the shop is marked up to sell, and the more time an item spends on the shelf, the steeper the discounts become.

In addition to offering excellent rates, Rockfish has a helpful and friendly staff. They are always delighted to assist you in finding what you need or to make suggestions if you are unsure of what you want.

Rockfish Yard Sale Shop is a must-visit location if you enjoy finding unique stuff at incredible prices or just love shopping at thrift stores in Fayetteville NC. Check out their amazing collection at the store.

Address: 7623 Rockfish Rd, Raeford, NC 28376, US

Phone: +1 910-565-3800

Get Directions

4th Johns

4th Johns - thrift stores fayetteville nc

A thrift shop called 4th Johns Thrift Store is situated in Fayetteville, North Carolina. It provides a huge selection of secondhand goods at reasonable prices, including clothes, shoes, furniture, electronics, books, and more.

The shop has been a local favorite for more than ten years and is renowned for its welcoming environment, helpful employees, and dedication to sustainability. 4th Johns offers a consignment programme for customers looking to sell their own things in addition to selling used goods.

The shop is committed to offering the neighborhood a distinctive and affordable buying experience and to encouraging environmentally friendly purchasing habits. It is one of the most loved thrift shops in Fayetteville. 

Phone: +1 910-418-0504


Thrifting is a sustainable yet trendy way to serve mother Earth.  It has become very popular these days, especially among the youth.  Where people look for more affordable yet fashionable stock, thrift stores in Fayetteville NC provide you exactly that. The main benefit of thrifting for customers is affordability.

They provide sustainable and affordable items while supporting charities and reducing loss. By purchasing second-hand products you are saving them from landfills. Here is the list of thrift shops in Fayetteville. To sum up, Fayetteville has a fantastic selection of thrift stores for deal hunters, collectors, and vintage enthusiasts.

You’re sure to discover something you love at one of these thrift stores, whether you’re looking for clothing, furniture, or unique decor items. These secondhand shops provide a unique shopping experience thanks to their low prices, welcoming employees, and eco-friendly business practices.

So the next time you’re in Fayetteville, make sure to check out these best thrift shops and see what they have to offer. Check out their amazing collection at the store. Happy thrifting! 

Latest articles

Marketplace Liquidation Review: Read Before Purchasing Ready

When it comes to buying products in bulk, one popular option is to buy...

9 Best Liquidation Stores in Charlotte in 2024

Buying discounted merchandise is quite popular and important these days. Most people want to...

9 Best Liquidation Pallets in Alabama for Quality Stuff (2024)

When individuals hear the word, “liquidation” they usually assume it to be out-of-business sales,...

More like this